Skip to main content

Comment on MBA's persona non grata status

Dilbert.com

Businessweek had this article MBAs: Public Enemy No. 1? After flipping through the slides (MBAs gone bad) you see a common theme (not the degree) and you wonder if the original title was "Harvard Business School - Public enemey number uno?", but got edited in the final draft.

There is a lot of discussion going on in the business schools (bschools) about the way management is being taught and if they are to be blamed for the current financial crisis. Is the bschool to be blamed in the first place?

Dilbert.com

Sure the short-term minded MBA’s may have caused the crisis. But there is another cause related to short-term-ism and that is the failure of managers (not just managers with MBAs) to recognize the risks associated with innovative new products (CDO’s, Credit Default Swaps, etc) and general lack of experience in nurturing innovation.

Managers bought into the idea that they could wait for innovative new products to grow in someone else’s backyard and move to acquire it at the right time (Wachovia purchase of Golden West's World Savings Bank, Merrill Lynch exposure to sub-prime). This strategy reduces the cost of development and reduces the risk of failure. Managers decides the right time to acquire by following there stock options spread which in theory is as good as listening to the customers or taking a long-term view, given the fact that markets are always forward looking.

Timing based on market, as we realize now, can often be guided by a shortsighted market chasing high returns only acheived in a market bubble (God forbidding we should remember the bust). In that case you sure will get your timing and risk assessment wrong.

Dilbert.com

A non-market measure will require a subjective decision which will be based on past experience in innovation management, deep knowledge of the product and the available skill set within your organization, usually such wealth of knowledge is trapped in human capital of your organization

Managing and nurturing innovation requires a long-term view and a wiliness to keep experienced and skilled human capital (people) within your organization. In the long run it will help create timely new products and services while retaining the capital for future growth. If a manager’s greatest asset is managing quarterly expectation then the manager shouldn’t be in the CEO’s office, a press secretary’s post will match her skill set.

Dilbert.com

CEO/manager who acquired the “in thing” and don’t seem to know how to make it work, will have to fight the permeating argument “look it’s working for someone” and will do the next best thing they learned (in bschool) transfer fixed cost to variable cost. Right sizing the organization to make it work, usually to meet quarterly forecast, though a good method if you know what to right size. Managers are rewarded to “make it work”, and they do exactly that “make it work” in the short-term or what I call the “duct tape managers”. Long term view is always in the sideline (waiting for Steve Jobs or someone like that to show up) and wrong decision too big to fail are made to work at the expense of the stakeholders.

This leads to the next issue what is truly driving leader’s (CEO) decision? Bschool training and/or markets.


Here are some reference website
Henry Mintzberg website
Productivity2008 (pdf) by Mintzberg

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Travel Deals website

New York Times has this interesting article about how companies are mining through travel data to find travel deal. Sifting Data to Uncover Travel Deals sites the following website. Farecast.com airfarewatchdog.com ( to find deals that include companies that don't share data) Flightstats.com (if you wanted to see which flightsare most prone to problems/delays) milemaven.com (best mileage programs) pointmaven.com (earn the most hotel points) update 4/22 read more about at consumerist . Cheaptickets.com sidestep.com

Text-to-speech application on the web

2010 update on text-to-speech read more here There aren't may text-to-speech application available online. It would be great if it could read you the complete webpage. NPR does it by allowing your to stream content of each page one after another (but then they are a radio station). So why not have website that will read you all the article in the page without having to buy any software. Bluegrind and new web 2.0 website in beta stage (serious beta stage!) will read you a news article, blog and they claim its like having a personal news anchor reading the news to you every day. It doesn't just stop at your computer, you can take it with you wherever you go. What are the other Text-to-Speech (TTS) web application out there? Not many but we have found some cool research sites that let you read text. The best of them all AT&T research website . Yes AT&T. This application will read in 15 voices/language, there is a 300 character limit to ...

NYC new Congestion Pricing or Fees or Tax depending on which side of the fence you are on <<< Global Warming

Read on PhysOrg.com The most controversial idea in the plan ( NYC Plan 2030 ), from the mayor's Office of Long-term Planning and Sustainability , is a proposal to charge motorists for driving into Manhattan below 86th Street on weekdays from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Trucks would be charged $21 a day and cars would be charged $8, on top of the city's already expensive parking. It is similar to a system that London (Congestion Charge) has used since 2003, and officials there say it has significantly reduced congestion. The scheme applauded by environmentalists and alternative transportation groups , but is politically tricky for New York City because it would have to be enacted by the state Legislature , and many lawmakers from outer boroughs and the suburbs may not support it. Read Full speech hear -- Click here